| #3 | DePauw | plays | #5 | Wooster |
| #4 | Denison | plays at | #8 | Kenyon |
| #1 | John Carroll | plays | #7 | Ohio Wesleyan |
| #8 | Kenyon | plays | #4 | Denison |
| #9 | Oberlin | plays | #2 | Wabash |
| #7 | Ohio Wesleyan | plays at | #1 | John Carroll |
| #2 | Wabash | plays at | #9 | Oberlin |
| #5 | Wooster | plays at | #3 | DePauw |